diff --git a/doc/release_notes.md b/doc/release_notes.md index 75bdb819..101938e6 100644 --- a/doc/release_notes.md +++ b/doc/release_notes.md @@ -24,6 +24,8 @@ * Added the process CO2 emissions of clinker calcination (`cement dry clinker`, `carbondioxide-output`, 0.52 t_CO2/t_clinker) and corrected the unit of its `heat-input` to MWh_th/t_clinker. () +* Added `afforestation restorative` as carbon dioxide removal technology, with investment per hectare of new forest. () + * Adding `Enhanced Weathering` (or Rocks) as CDR technology. () * Add cost assumptions for water network infrastructure: water pipeline HDPE and water pipeline booster pump () diff --git a/inputs/manual_input.csv b/inputs/manual_input.csv index 5fc52cdc..64b892fe 100644 --- a/inputs/manual_input.csv +++ b/inputs/manual_input.csv @@ -757,4 +757,7 @@ water pipeline HDPE (171.65mm 16 bar),lifetime,2023,50,years,2022,"HYPAT_WP_Wate water pipeline booster pump,investment,1981,4775,EUR/kW,2022,"Calculated based on HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf, Sec. 4.3 + 8.1, Eq. 17 and Monterey County report (1981) using 2% annual inflation; accessed 2026-06-15","Cost of water booster pump per horsepower scaled via power law (exponent 0.558). Base value 15,570 USD/HP (1981) inflated to 2022 and converted using an exchange rate of 0.7532 EUR/USD. Value evaluated at reference pump capacity (~73 kW) corresponding to 4,775 EUR/kW." water pipeline booster pump,FOM,1981,2,%/year,2022,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf, Sec. 4.3 + 8.1; accessed 2026-06-15", water pipeline booster pump,lifetime,1981,30,years,2022,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf, Sec. 4.3 + 8.1; accessed 2026-06-15", -water pipeline booster pump,efficiency,1981,0.765,m^3-H2O/kWh,2022,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf, Sec. 4.3 + 8.1, by multiplying the motor efficiency with the pump efficiency: 0.85 x 0.9=0.765; accessed 2026-06-15", \ No newline at end of file +water pipeline booster pump,efficiency,1981,0.765,m^3-H2O/kWh,2022,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf, Sec. 4.3 + 8.1, by multiplying the motor efficiency with the pump efficiency: 0.85 x 0.9=0.765; accessed 2026-06-15", +afforestation restorative,lifetime,2025,30,years,-,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests. +afforestation restorative,FOM,2025,0,%/year,2020,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment." +afforestation restorative,investment,2025,9574,EUR/ha,2020,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed." diff --git a/outputs/US/costs_2020.csv b/outputs/US/costs_2020.csv index 924613c9..bf040748 100644 --- a/outputs/US/costs_2020.csv +++ b/outputs/US/costs_2020.csv @@ -3492,6 +3492,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2481,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,348122.7696,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0,, +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests.,,, air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0,, air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .",,, air separation unit,investment,1266591.4581,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0,, diff --git a/outputs/US/costs_2025.csv b/outputs/US/costs_2025.csv index 70e2a32f..695401b1 100644 --- a/outputs/US/costs_2025.csv +++ b/outputs/US/costs_2025.csv @@ -3572,6 +3572,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2362,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,324451.5425,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0,, +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests.,,, air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0,, air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .",,, air separation unit,investment,1151269.6095,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0,, diff --git a/outputs/US/costs_2030.csv b/outputs/US/costs_2030.csv index 817b3b36..c7703693 100644 --- a/outputs/US/costs_2030.csv +++ b/outputs/US/costs_2030.csv @@ -3728,6 +3728,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2244,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,300780.3155,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0,, +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests.,,, air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0,, air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .",,, air separation unit,investment,1035947.761,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0,, diff --git a/outputs/US/costs_2035.csv b/outputs/US/costs_2035.csv index 4e8729c9..e5cf21b6 100644 --- a/outputs/US/costs_2035.csv +++ b/outputs/US/costs_2035.csv @@ -3752,6 +3752,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2244,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,300780.3155,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0,, +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests.,,, air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0,, air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .",,, air separation unit,investment,941625.7836,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0,, diff --git a/outputs/US/costs_2040.csv b/outputs/US/costs_2040.csv index b487fe02..59c8f668 100644 --- a/outputs/US/costs_2040.csv +++ b/outputs/US/costs_2040.csv @@ -3752,6 +3752,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2244,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,300780.3155,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0,, +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests.,,, air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0,, air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .",,, air separation unit,investment,847303.8062,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0,, diff --git a/outputs/US/costs_2045.csv b/outputs/US/costs_2045.csv index a7b497b4..6fa9823a 100644 --- a/outputs/US/costs_2045.csv +++ b/outputs/US/costs_2045.csv @@ -3752,6 +3752,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2244,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,300780.3155,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0,, +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests.,,, air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0,, air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .",,, air separation unit,investment,748444.8272,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0,, diff --git a/outputs/US/costs_2050.csv b/outputs/US/costs_2050.csv index df5fdef9..f3150609 100644 --- a/outputs/US/costs_2050.csv +++ b/outputs/US/costs_2050.csv @@ -3752,6 +3752,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2244,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,300780.3155,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0,, Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0,, +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0,, +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests.,,, air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0,, air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .",,, air separation unit,investment,649585.8482,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0,, diff --git a/outputs/costs_2020.csv b/outputs/costs_2020.csv index 6ef05d6d..639b3be1 100644 --- a/outputs/costs_2020.csv +++ b/outputs/costs_2020.csv @@ -622,6 +622,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2481,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,348122.7696,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0 +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0 +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0 +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests., air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0 air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .", air separation unit,investment,1266591.4581,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0 diff --git a/outputs/costs_2025.csv b/outputs/costs_2025.csv index a4543553..44aa8011 100644 --- a/outputs/costs_2025.csv +++ b/outputs/costs_2025.csv @@ -622,6 +622,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2362,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,324451.5425,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0 +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0 +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0 +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests., air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0 air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .", air separation unit,investment,1151269.6095,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0 diff --git a/outputs/costs_2030.csv b/outputs/costs_2030.csv index 55f0e830..a673f2bf 100644 --- a/outputs/costs_2030.csv +++ b/outputs/costs_2030.csv @@ -622,6 +622,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2244,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,300780.3155,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0 +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0 +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0 +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests., air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0 air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .", air separation unit,investment,1035947.761,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0 diff --git a/outputs/costs_2035.csv b/outputs/costs_2035.csv index a4726482..bb4e29a9 100644 --- a/outputs/costs_2035.csv +++ b/outputs/costs_2035.csv @@ -622,6 +622,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2244,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,300780.3155,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0 +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0 +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0 +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests., air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0 air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .", air separation unit,investment,941625.7836,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0 diff --git a/outputs/costs_2040.csv b/outputs/costs_2040.csv index a7248217..495a2d1b 100644 --- a/outputs/costs_2040.csv +++ b/outputs/costs_2040.csv @@ -622,6 +622,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2244,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,300780.3155,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0 +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0 +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0 +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests., air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0 air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .", air separation unit,investment,847303.8062,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0 diff --git a/outputs/costs_2045.csv b/outputs/costs_2045.csv index 75a677a4..f8105fbc 100644 --- a/outputs/costs_2045.csv +++ b/outputs/costs_2045.csv @@ -622,6 +622,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2244,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,300780.3155,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0 +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0 +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0 +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests., air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0 air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .", air separation unit,investment,748444.8272,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0 diff --git a/outputs/costs_2050.csv b/outputs/costs_2050.csv index 8bd4abfd..9f6b4a9b 100644 --- a/outputs/costs_2050.csv +++ b/outputs/costs_2050.csv @@ -622,6 +622,9 @@ Zn-Br-Nonflow-bicharger,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'c Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,FOM,0.2244,%/year,"Viswanathan_2022, 0.43 % of SB","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['derived']}",2020.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,investment,300780.3155,EUR/MWh,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81) Table 4.14","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['DC storage block']}",2025.0 Zn-Br-Nonflow-store,lifetime,15.0,years,"Viswanathan_2022, p.59 (p.81)","{'carrier': ['znbr'], 'technology_type': ['store'], 'type': ['electrochemical'], 'note': ['NULL']}",2020.0 +afforestation restorative,FOM,0.0,%/year,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1",Maintenance occurs in years 1-5 only and is included in the investment.,2020.0 +afforestation restorative,investment,12037.7215,EUR/ha,"Bodin et al. (2021), Restoration Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13515, Table 1","Per ha of new forest, row Planted forests (for restoration). 30% of upper bounds: 0.3 x (25,830 USD establishment + 2,421 USD/a maintenance x 4.3872) = 10,935 USD, where 4.3872 = sum of 1.07^-k for k = 0..4 (NPV at 7%). 1.1422 USD/EUR (ECB 2020 average); currency year assumed.",2025.0 +afforestation restorative,lifetime,30.0,years,Guesstimate.,Duration of the fast-growth phase of new forests., air separation unit,FOM,3.0,%/year,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Fixed O&M,2015.0 air separation unit,electricity-input,0.25,MWh_el/t_N2,"DEA (2022): Technology Data for Renewable Fuels (https://ens.dk/en/our-services/projections-and-models/technology-data/technology-data-renewable-fuels), p.288.","For consistency reasons use value from Danish Energy Agency. DEA also reports range of values (0.2-0.4 MWh/t_N2) on pg. 288. Other efficienices reported are even higher, e.g. 0.11 Mwh/t_N2 from Morgan (2013): Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of Ammonia Plants Powered by Offshore Wind .", air separation unit,investment,649585.8482,EUR/t_N2/h,"Danish Energy Agency, inputs/data_sheets_for_renewable_fuels.xlsx",103 Hydrogen to Ammonia: Specific investment,2025.0