Repository navigation
Confidence 10/10 · No issues found
🟢 Confidence 10/10 · safe to merge. Copy-only change; the account of the Grafana and Perses importers matches the code, one page answer is left inconsistent.
1 note · tests not needed · risk low
Corrects the landing comparison pages and the Dash0 alternatives data to say Maple runs PromQL for metrics and imports Grafana dashboards, keeping Prometheus alert rules as the gap. Copy is consistent across the three locales and safe to merge; one page answer still reads as if Maple had no PromQL.
cmp_gf_promql_mapleand the Grafana migration step now describe dashboards importing with their PromQL panels- Dash0 and SigNoz pages mark PromQL alert rules, not PromQL, as the gap
- The alternatives table marks Maple
promql: "Yes"and drops its "No PromQL" con - English, Japanese and Korean strings move together
Findings
🔵 Note · F9 · promql: "Yes" contradicts the page's "Must self-host and keep PromQL" answer
correctness · apps/landing/src/lib/alternatives.ts:131
Maple's row now reads PromQL Yes and self-hostable, but the short answer printed directly above the table (alternatives.ts:95-97) still sends teams that "must self-host and keep PromQL" to SigNoz or Grafana, and SigNoz's pickIf (alternatives.ts:152) repeats it. A reader with that requirement is told Maple does not fit, then sees a row saying it does.
Add Maple to the picks (self-hosted, without alerting yet), or note the alerting caveat in that answer and in SigNoz's `pickIf`.
What was checked
- Grafana importer keeps PromQL verbatim and turns rows into sections (
grafana-import-panels.ts:66,grafana-dashboard-import.test.ts:55) - PromQL panels that cannot render land as placeholders with a report entry (
grafana-import-panels.ts:268-272) - No other landing page or doc still claims Maple has no PromQL (grep over
apps/landingat the head)
9d6cb5f · Reply "won't fix" to dismiss a finding, or mention @maple-review-bot to ask about one.
Annotations
Check notice on line 131 in apps/landing/src/lib/alternatives.ts
maple-review-bot / Maple / review
correctness: `promql: "Yes"` contradicts the page's "Must self-host and keep PromQL" answer
Maple's row now reads PromQL `Yes` and self-hostable, but the short answer printed directly above the table (`alternatives.ts:95-97`) still sends teams that "must self-host and keep PromQL" to SigNoz or Grafana, and SigNoz's `pickIf` (`alternatives.ts:152`) repeats it. A reader with that requirement is told Maple does not fit, then sees a row saying it does.